(E) Ages 12-15, (F) Ages 15-18, Book Reviews, Fairy/Folk Tale/Myth, Fantasy, Middle Grades, Romance, Teen/YA
Leave a comment

Briar and Rose and Jack by Katherine Coville

Briar and Rose and Jack mixes fairy-tale motifs with clear themes of good and evil in a magical and satisfying adventure.

Briar and Rose and Jack by Katherine Coville. Clarion (HMH), 2019, 360 pages.

Reading level: Teen, ages 12-15

Recommended for: ages 12-18

King Warrick and his wife were not expecting twins, but the king is mightily relieved when, after the first baby emerged with an misshapen face, the second is beautiful and perfect. Under the advisement of Bishop Simon, the king is easily persuaded to present pretty Rose as his daughter and heir, and ugly Briar as the offspring of a noble couple recently deceased. The midwife, who has some magical powers, feels an attachment to Briar and is determined she won’t be left out when the good fairies arrive to bestow their magical gifts on the baby. So Briar gets a share of Rose’s blessings without anyone knowing. Then the gray fairy appears, furious at the king’s failure to invite her to the party, and hurls a death curse at the child—death at the age of sixteen, after pricking her finger on a spindle. Things get a bit confused there—did the curse land on Briar or on Rose?

As the girls grow up, an evil giant begins making raids on the kingdom, demanding gold and grain. The king gives in every time, making his subjects poorer and hungrier while hoarding goodies for himself. One brave lad named Jack decides that something must be done . . .

As she did in The Cottage in the Woods, Katherine Coville mixes familiar elements of fairy tale with literary and even biblical themes (such as “the last shall be first”). Unlike Cottage, however, the plot moves quickly and the third-person narrative is lighter in tone. The twins’ relationship is loving but complex, developing over the span of sixteen years in which both have to deal with the different burdens of ugliness and beauty. Unlike many fairy-tale reimaginings, heroes don’t come in for reevaluation against sword-wielding heroines. The boys are properly valiant, resourceful, and self-sacrificing. Villains are not so well-rounded. The giant is just a brutal, dimwitted giant, but the king is utterly feckless and the bishop is cruel, greedy, and foolish. This is an indictment of the man, not the church, or religion in general, as other characters display deep faith. The unalloyed villainy throws heroism in sharp relief, to make for a very satisfying ending.

Overall rating: 4 (out of 5)

  • Worldview/moral value: 3.75
  • Artistic/literary value: 4.5

Considerations:

  • A few instances of medieval style swearing (i.e., “God’s teeth”).
  • One minor character is described as gazing lustfully at Princess Rose, but the prevalent romantic relationships are chaste and noble.
  • Hilde, the midwife, has some characteristics of a witch and is seen casting spells, but most of these are for comic effect.
  • Briar and Rose have an interesting discussion about good and evil on page 194, on the order of, does it pay to be good if there’s no reward? And is it still bad to be evil if your evil affects no one else? These ideas might be worth discussing.

For more fairy-tale reimaginings, see Hayley’s thoughts on “Reading Robin McKinley” as well as our month-long deep dive into the Christian understanding of “Beauty and the Beast.” We’ve reviewed another version of Sleeping Beauty that’s set in a New England mill town: Spindle.

We are participants in the Amazon LLC affiliate program; purchases you make through affiliate links like the one below earn us a commission.

rel=”nofollow”
Please follow and like us:
error

Leave a Reply

Your email address will not be published. Required fields are marked *