Betsy and Janie, the middle-grade readers, are joining forces today to tell you about three brand-new fantasy series for middle-graders. Betsy reviews the first two, Janie the last:
Jinx by Sage Blackwood. HarperCollins, 2013. 368 pages. Age/interest level: 4th-8th grades. Jinx is a delightful new fantasy series for middle grade readers with an older magician, an untrained apprentice, fantastic creatures (witches, trolls, werebears), solid world-building, a suspenseful quest, and dramatic plot twists. It’s hard to say which part of this novel was the most well done. Jinx is a very likable hero for whom the reader can’t help but cheer. Simon, the older magician, is surly and suspicious; we’re never quite sure we can trust him. The Urwald seems a truly magical place; Jinx can even feel the trees with his toes. The supporting cast of characters are each unique and complex. And the bad guy is really, truly creepy.
Blackwood succeeds in keeping the reader in the dark, though, as to who the good guys (and bad) really are. A shred of doubt pricks at the back of your mind: can we trust the witch? What about Simon? What about Jinx’s friend? What is the trouble that is approaching that only the trees seem to know about? I appreciated how complex the good/bad issue is: isn’t that the way life is? It’s sometimes hard to tell who we can trust. The devil is the father of lies and quite good at deception.
The close of this book is open-ended enough to hint at future books (and yes, there is one coming out in early 2014!), but resolved enough that it could stand alone. That’s a hard ending to pull off, and it makes this book that much stronger for it. All in all, this is an intriguing new fantasy series, and it will appeal to fans of high fantasy. I, for one, will be reading book two!
- Moral/worldview rating: 4 (out of 5)
- Literary rating: 4
Wild Born by Brandon Mull (Spirit Animals, book 1). Scholastic, 2013. 238 pages. Age/interest level: Middle grades (4th-8th) but accessible to younger, strong readers.
Mull, the author of the popular Fablehaven series, is back with a new fantasy series for his young fans: Spirit Animals. In the world Mull creates, 11-year-olds drink a special Nectar during a coming-of-age ceremony, and the fortunate ones call up and bond with a spirit animal. Only those that succeed in calling up a spirit animal are able to join the elite Greencloaks. Spirit animals, once bonded to their humans, can go dormant in tattoo form on their human, or become active and, through their spiritual connection, assist their humans in various endeavors. Wild Born introduces readers to four young people who have each just called one of the famous Four Fallen: four spirit animals that were once part of the Great Animals and who fell in an epic battle for the planet (Erdas) centuries previously. Prophecies have indicated their return as well as the return of the Devourer–the main evil dude–and his cronies. Will the Four Fallen and their young human partners be able to help the good forces of Erdas defeat the Devourer once again?
A fun series for those who love animals and a good fantasy read, Wild Born will no doubt please Mull’s existing fans and garner some new ones. The world building is not as strong as great classic fantasy (in fact, Erdas and its continents bear a distinct resemblance to Earth), the characterization falls into classic stock character types, and the plot is a touch predictable in parts. Still, for those young readers in their own devouring stage, the ones who can read an entire fantasy series in an afternoon, this will no doubt be a welcome new experience. The idea of spirit animals is unique and one kids will likely enjoy.
**updated 9/13/13 to add: See Betsy’s comment below for more information on this unusual series.
- Moral/worldview rating: 3.5
- Literary rating: 3
An Army of Frogs (The Kulipari, book 1), by Trevor Price and Joel Naftali, illustrated by 
Sanford Greene. Abrams, 272 pp. Age/interest level: 8-12.
This new animal-fantasy series stars an earnest young amphibian with a noble pedigree and heroic dreams that far exceed his size. Readers may be reminded of Matthias of Redwall, an earnest young rodent with heroic dreams, etc.–and that might not be amiss. Instead of Cluny the rat and his weaselly minions, it’s Lord Marmoo and his scorpion hoards (assisted by Jarrah the spider Queen), who threaten the peace and serenity of Amphibiland. It all shakes out in a rather routine but entertaining manner, with some clever twists on the froggy paradigm, such as getting “ponded” instead of grounded, or “catching two flies with one lick” in place of the familiar proverb about killing two birds. The full-color illustrations are reminiscent of Saturday morning cartoons, and there’s some thematic fluff about following one’s heart, but it’s a harmless diversion for middle graders (especially boys) who are clamoring “What can I read next?”
- Moral/worldview rating: 3.5
- Literary rating: 3
For more middle-grade fantasy, see our reviews of The Emerald Atlas, the Wingfeather Saga, The Dragon’s Tooth, Small Persons with Wings, Artemis Fowl, The Unwanteds, A Tangle of Knots, Cardboard, and Tuesdays at the Castle. Animal fans will also like Mr. and Mrs. Bunny and our collection of “Mouse Tales.”
Stay Up to Date!
Get the information you need to make wise choices about books for your children and teens.
Our weekly newsletter includes our latest reviews, related links from around the web, a featured book list, book trivia, and more. We never sell your information. You may unsubscribe at any time.
Support our writers and help keep Redeemed Reader ad-free by joining the Redeemed Reader Fellowship.
Stay Up to Date!
Get the information you need to make wise choices about books for your children and teens.
Our weekly newsletter includes our latest reviews, related links from around the web, a featured book list, book trivia, and more. We never sell your information. You may unsubscribe at any time.
We'd love to hear from you!
Our comments are now limited to our members (both Silver and Golden Key). Members, you just need to log in with your normal log-in credentials!
Not a member yet? You can join the Silver Key ($2.99/month) for a free 2-week trial. Cancel at any time. Find out more about membership here.
4 Comments
Leave a Comment
You must be logged in to post a comment.
There’s more to the Wild Born/Spirit Animals story that may be of interest: this is apart of a new multi-platform series in which different authors will be writing different books of the series (some are quite well known) and for which an online game will also be part of the experience. I received a digital advance copy, so my review reflects the text only of the first book. It’s a series to watch, both for the ways in which it’s making use of 21st century technology to bring a different reading experience about and also for the authors that end up writing the rest of the series.
And, I forgot to include the link for more info! https://www.publishersweekly.com/pw/by-topic/childrens/childrens-book-news/article/55434-scholastic-to-roll-out-new-multi-platform-series.html
I am curious if you are endorsing these books from a Christian perspective? I personally think they are terrible, exposing children to magic and spirit animals/guides which seems to be entirely demonic and not at all Christian.
I did find this link – https://www.gotquestions.org/spirit-guides.html
that helps explain my perspective.
Thanks for your comment, Raina. This is a hard area to discuss sometimes in the virtual world (as opposed to face-to-face and with a particular book in hand). You’re right that the concept of spirit guides as per the website link you provided is a questionable one, an area in which we do well to exercise great caution. That being said, at least in the first book in the Spirit Animal series, I didn’t get the impression that anything demonic was being suggested. It reminds me of much of the milder fantasy that targets middle grades.
Perhaps a bigger question would be the question of fantasy in general. Different families address this question differently, some choosing to read fantasy discerningly and some not to read it at all. At RedeemedReader, we believe it’s okay to read fantasy provided we are reading discerningly (as with all books!), and we also think it’s important to review fantasy works. You’ll note that Spirit Animals doesn’t garner a terribly high worldview rating, and, depending on where the series goes, it may need to be knocked down another notch or two. We’ll keep an eye on this whole phenomenon. With the addition of games and virtual reality associated with this series (a feature that wasn’t available on the e-book I reviewed pre-publication), the good/bad qualities will no doubt be more prominent and we should judge accordingly. Part of the reason a book like Jinx gets a higher worldview rating is that there is a very strong good v. evil component in that book, strong characterization showing maturation and recognition of the nuances of morality, and the like–in short, thematic elements that bring up great discussion and which reinforce the right sorts of directions.
If you’re curious about our general take on fantasy (including fairy tales, witches, etc.–all of which have been judged by some to be inappropriate for Christians), you might be interested to see some of our previous discussions. Megan brought up the question of fairy tales here: https://redeemedreader.com/2013/06/what-about-fairy-tales/. Emily opened a discussion on fantasy with witches and wizards here: https://redeemedreader.com/2013/02/coffee-and-controversy-with-a-cup-of-kindness/
Part of what we try to do here is to help readers develop discernment, even modeling it in such ongoing series as our recent Ender’s Game readalong (https://redeemedreader.com/2013/09/enders-game-read-along-a-galactic-giveaway-and-contest/). But these are definitely areas fraught with questions. We don’t have all the answers and we so much appreciate our readers taking the time to engage with us and help us evaluate literature. We’ll be keeping an eye on these books. For now, it’s worth pointing out that a review of a work is different from a recommendation. Books like the ones above don’t usually make our recommendations lists for general use; they are more for a particular audience (and in this case, one that’s okay with fantasy)–I’d direct you to books like the ones listed in our Winter Book Fair and discussed in that accompanying podcast for books we heartily recommend: https://redeemedreader.com/2013/11/winter-book-fair-gift-books-to-support-redeemedreader/
Thanks for reading along with us and taking the time to comment!