Have an Awesome Thanksgiving

In honor of this week’s holiday, a book review post from a few years back:

*Sarah Gives Thanks: How Thanksgiving Became a National Holiday, by Mike Allegra, illustrated by David Gardner.  Whitman, 2012, 32 pages.

Age-interest level: 4-up

As our story opens, Sarah Hale is gathered with her five children around the Thanksgiving table.  No one looks happy, and no wonder: “They had just returned from their father’s grave and were not in a thankful mood.”  Sarah herself, while grieving for her beloved husband, carries the additional burden of feeding her family.  But she bows her head: “Dear Lord, we’re thankful for having known him.  We are thankful for his love.  And we are thankful for the love we have for each other.”  Silently she adds a prayer for gainful employment.

The next pages show how her prayer was answered, and then some.  A lifelong reader and writer, Sarah was soon able to support her family through her poems and stories, and eventually as the editor of the phenomenally popular journal, Godey’s Ladies Book.  By this account, she was the Oprah of her day, whose recommendations could create best-sellers and whose advice could set trends.  She campaigned for expanded educational opportunities for women and recognition for historical monuments, and sometime in the 1840s decided that Thanksgiving—generally celebrated only in New England—should be a national holiday.  She began a letter-writing campaign and invited her readers to join.  The purpose of all the letters was to persuade the president of the United States to make the declaration of a national holiday.  Four presidents in a row said no.  The fifth had a different point of view, forced on him by circumstances:

Lincoln understood that sometimes it was hard to remember good things in hard times.  People needed a day to be thankful for food on their tables, roofs over their heads and the blessings in their lives.

The gentle watercolor illustrations show Sarah and her children growing older until the final page, where she holds a grandchild surrounded by grown sons and daughters, each face an echo of her prayer of thanks from the first page.

Thank You Sarah: The Woman Who Saved Thanksgiving, by Laurie Halse Anderson, illustrated by Matt Faulkner.  Simon & Schuster, 2002, 32 pages.

Age/interest level: 5-up.

You think you know everything about Thanksgiving, don’t you?  How the Native Americans saved the Pilgrims from starving [and] how the Pilgrims held a big feast to celebrate and say thank you . . . Well listen up.  I have a news flash . . .

The author’s news flash is that Thanksgiving was fading away and would have disappeared from the American calendar altogether if it weren’t for Sarah Hale.  “Not only did she fight for Thanksgiving, she fought for playgrounds for kids, schools for girls, and historical monuments for everyone.”   That sets the tone: Mrs. Hale as activist crusader rather than the devout, hard-working and family-centered person she seems to have been.  There is no mention of her beloved husband or the primary reason she turned to writing: as a way to support her family.  Not much either about what Thanksgiving actually means—apparently Sarah campaigned for the holiday because she loved it and thought it would be a good thing for everybody.

The illustrations are clever, slightly cartoonish and often symbolic: for instance, on one page the women of America hoist a giant quill pen to storm a generic state house, which of course is stuffed by men who take refuge behind the motto: GO AWAY WE’RE BUSY.  Sarah doesn’t age during the thirty-year process, appearing as an epic figure in page after page.  But I doubt that she would have wrapped herself in the feminist mantle, for even though she believed firmly in women’s education, she also believed that men and women occupied separate spheres of influence.  When asked to take on the editor’s job at Godey’s in Philadelphia, she preferred the title “editress” and asked to do her work from Boston until her son graduated from Harvard.  No doubt Sarah was “bold, brave, stubborn, and smart,” but the superhero label Anderson seems determined to stick on her is over the top.  I like the human stature of Sarah Gives Thanks a lot better: a good woman, by all accounts, and that’s “super” enough.

Apple, by Nikki McClure, Abrams Appleseed 2012, 40 pages.

Age/interest level: 3-up.

Apple was the first cut-paper artwork by Nikki McClure, who created the book sixteen years ago and liked it so much she printed copies at Kinko’s to sell online.  This year sees its publication in hardcover by Abrams.  It’s tells a basic storyline in one-word paragraphs: an apple falls from a tree and meets a fate different from its peers.  In fact, this is one of those rare apples that makes it to tree-hood.  The illustrations are simple but striking in black and white with touches of red; they remind me of seventeenth-century woodcuts.  A paragraph at the end explains the life cycle of an apple tree and the optimum conditions for planting.  Though beautifully produced, it may appeal more to adults than kids.  But little ones will enjoy putting the sequence together, and before long they’ll be able to “read” the story to you.

The Thankful Book, by Todd Parr.  Little, Brown, 2012, 32 pages.  Age/interest level: 3-up.

An Awesome Book of Thanks! by Dallas Clayton.  HarperCollins, 2012, 83 pages.  Age/interest level: 4-up

Todd Parr is best known for simple theme books (on bullying, family, manners, diversity) that look like they could have been illustrated by their intended audience: smiley stick figures in bright primary colors.  Dallas Clayton writes on similar themes in a similar style—his figures are just as smiley and colorful but all seem to come from Planet Egg: at least, that’s the general shape of them.  Like Nikki McClure, he self-published his picture books (starting with An Awesome Book! In 2008) and promoted them so effectively he caught the interest first of Amazon Encore and next of HarperCollins.  Dallas sounds like a terrific guy and for a few pages at a time this is a terrific book.  “Thanks for trees and thanks for trains and for the breeze and for the rain and thanks for books to fill my brain.”  He has a rare gift for rhyming and an exuberant style but, like Todd Parr (and many other authors of Thanksgiving picture books), he can’t bring himself to thank anyone in particular for all this great stuff.  So he gives thanks to the things he’s thankful for, which should cause any self-respecting four-year-old to scratch his head and say “Huh?”

One good thing both these books do is call to mind “thanks-worthy” things that kids might overlook, like shadows and bubble baths (Parr) and unpleasant experiences (Clayton): “Those bad things can turn out to be good/Those bumps and those bruises that turn ‘couldn’ts’ to ‘coulds’ . . .”  And that’s all to the good, as long as the kids remember Him to Whom thanks is due.

ONE MORE: This is not really a Thanksgiving book, but our friend Simonetta Carr reminds us that the history of Thanksgiving goes back a lot farther than Sarah Hale.  There were these people called Pilgrims . . . an offshoot of another religious movement called Puritans . . .  And one of the greatest Puritan thinkers of all time was John Owen.   Though Owen never migrated to the New World, his life paralleled that of the Pilgrims and he had to deal with the same church/state issues they did.  His life will shed some light on why the Pilgrim band believed they had to leave Europe in the first place, and for a short time only, Simonetta Carr’s excellent biography for children, John Owen, is available from Reformation Heritage Books for only $8.10!  Look for it here and get your copy today.

Check out our Thanksgiving posts from last year: a chat with Susan Hunt (including recipes!),  Emily’s roundup of Thanksgiving books, Janie’s collection of literary cookbooks, and a great biography of Myles Standish.

Download a free annotated list of our favorite Thanksgiving books here!

We are participants in the Amazon LLC affiliate program; purchases you make through affiliate links like the one below earn us a commission.


Stay Up to Date!

Get the information you need to make wise choices about books for your children and teens.

Our weekly newsletter includes our latest reviews, related links from around the web, a featured book list, book trivia, and more. We never sell your information. You may unsubscribe at any time.

Something went wrong. Please check your entries and try again.

Support our writers and help keep Redeemed Reader ad-free by joining the Redeemed Reader Fellowship.

Use code Redeemed15 for 15% off!

Stay Up to Date!

Get the information you need to make wise choices about books for your children and teens.

Our weekly newsletter includes our latest reviews, related links from around the web, a featured book list, book trivia, and more. We never sell your information. You may unsubscribe at any time.

Something went wrong. Please check your entries and try again.

Janie Cheaney

Janie is the VERY senior staff writer for Redeemed Reader, as well as a long-time contributor to WORLD Magazine and an author of nine books for children. The rest of the time she's long-distance smooching on her four grandchildren (not an easy task). She lives with her equally senior husband of almost-fifty years in the Ozarks of Missouri.

We'd love to hear from you!

Our comments are now limited to our members (both Silver and Golden Key). Members, you just need to log in with your normal log-in credentials!

Not a member yet? You can join the Silver Key ($2.99/month) for a free 2-week trial. Cancel at any time. Find out more about membership here.


  1. Gina on November 13, 2012 at 3:19 pm

    Thank you for the reviews! I’m looking forward to reading both Sarah books with my 7 year old so we can talk about the different point of view – great thinking and discernment material! I love how even the title points to the difference: Sarah giving thanks versus being thanked. Like Dallas Clayton, Anderson seems to misplace the object of thanksgiving. I’m reserving them from the library now.

  2. Gina on November 13, 2012 at 3:23 pm

    Do you have any favorite books about early thanksgiving and harvest celebrations of the colonists?

  3. Janie Cheaney on November 14, 2012 at 2:11 pm

    Gina, Emily has plenty of reviews about the Pilgrims and Thanksgiving in the link at the end of my post, but I can’t think of any resources dealing with the colonists. As both books about Sarah Hale imply, Thanksgiving wasn’t celebrated with any degree of regularity, so there might not be much available. It would be interesting to find out though–maybe next year!

  4. Thanks to Sarah | Janie B. Cheaney on November 17, 2018 at 8:20 am

    […] picture books about Sarah Hale have been published in the last decade: Sarah Gives Thanks, by Mike Allegra, and Thank You, Sarah by Laurie Halse Anderson.  The titles might give you a hint […]

Leave a Comment

You must be logged in to post a comment.