Bright Star: The Story of Esther by Holly Mackle, illustrated by Marlena Sigman

Bright Star is a lively-written volume in Kaleidoscope’s series of Bible storybooks for elementary-age children that adds helpful context to the Scriptural account.

Bright Star: The Story of Esther by Holly Mackle, illustrated by Marlena Sigman. Kaleidoscope, 2022. 53 pages.

Reading Level: Middle Grades, Ages 10-12

Recommended For: Ages 10-12

Kaleidoscope has an interesting approach to children’s Bibles. Since there are sixty-six books in the Old and New Testaments combined, it’s a kind of library, right? Kaleidoscope is publishing narrative versions of individual books of the Bible (sometimes two or three together, when appropriate) as a bridge for elementary aged children who might be overwhelmed by reading the whole Bible.

Bright Star is the story of Esther, beginning with historical and cultural context. Why were the Jews still in Persia? Didn’t they all go back home when they had a chance? Then the stage is set with the meaning of Esther’s name, “star,” indicating how she will shine brightly in the darkness. The text is drawn carefully from the biblical account. Without embellishing the text in a way that would veer from Scripture, Mackle provides details that help the reader imagine the events more vividly.

I enjoy Mackle’s lively writing. As a school librarian she write capably to her audience, understanding the appeal of a villain, but NOT romance at that age. Extra “Kaleidoscope Corners” add insight on difficult topics such as the submission of a wife to her husband, enmity, sovereignty and providence, and how the book of Esther points to Jesus.

The volumes are slim hardcovers in a size that is easy to carry, with attractive cover designs that either boys or girls would generally be comfortable with. Although the book is intended for an elementary-age audience, the limited white space on the pages and denser font would make it harder for emerging readers to tackle for themselves. Take the confidence of your reader into consideration when determining whether to make this book a read-aloud or independent choice. The colors in the illustrations also seem heavy and dark, and much of the action seems to happen at night. I understand the symbolism of the bright star at night, but less color saturation would have helped balance the pages.

Overall these are good for a home library, suitable choices for Easter baskets. Bright Star may be purchased directly from Kaleidoscope, from Westminster Kids, and elsewhere.

Overall Rating: 4.25 out of 5 (Heading 4; not bold)

• Worldview/Moral Rating: 5 out of 5
• Literary/Artistic Rating: 4 out of 5

Read more about our ratings here.

Related Reading From Redeemed Reader:

• A Review: Little Hearts Prepare Him Room A lovely resource for advent by Holly Mackle.
• A Resource: See our recommendations in The Good Book category.