(E) Ages 12-15, (F) Ages 15-18, Book Reviews, Multicultural, Realistic Fiction
comments 2

Piecing Me Together by Renee Watson

In Piecing Me Together, a Newbery honor book, a black teen in a low-income neighborhood carves out a place in the world through art and mentorship.  Ages 12-15

Piecing Me Together by Renee Watson.  Bloomsbury, 207, 261 pages.

Reading Level: Teen, ages 12-15

Recommended for: ages 12-15

“The only thing fancy about me is my name: Jade. But I am not precious like a gem.  There is nothing exquisite about my life. It’s mine, though, so I’m going to make something of it.”  That’s an admirable goal, and Jade has the brains and talent to make better than “something” of her life.  The negatives are there, too: she’s black, she’s female (and on the heavy side), and she’s poor.  The only child of a single mom with a dead-end job, Jade lives on the north side of Portland and rides the city bus every day to St. Francis School.  She has a scholarship and her mother insists she take advantage of it.  Jade agrees in principle but it’s hard to engage when she misses her friends from the old school and can’t find her place at the almost-all-white one.  Nor is she excited about the program she’s invited to join, a mentorship called Woman to Woman–especially when she has reason to doubt the motives of the mentor matched to her.  But this will be the year it begins to come together: new friends, new opportunities, and the first tenuous steps toward a new life.

The word is never mentioned, but Jade is a picture of “intersectionality”: the struggles of being black intersect with the struggles of being female. Though the concept is too politicized (like so much else), I got a better understanding of it by spending time with this character.  Unlike The Hate U Give, no cataclysmic event shapes the plot.  As in a collage, her favorite art medium, snippets of history, home life, friends, and old and new experiences come together to make her a different person at the end: confident, assured, and more accepting of herself and others.  Art is Jade’s way of “piecing herself together”; though prayer is mentioned, faith doesn’t seem to have a big claim on her life.

Cautions: Language (a few misuses of God’s name)

Overall Rating: 3.5 (out of 5)

  • Worldview/moral value: 3.5
  • Artistic value: 3.5

 

Please follow and like us:

2 Comments

  1. Meredith Burton says

    I enjoyed Piecintg Me Together very much. While The Hate U Give is more attention-grabbing, I felt that the quietness of Piecing Me Together was more resonant. I especially liked how the relationship between the main character and her mentor changed throughout the story; how the characters were multi-layered and real. The book showed how racism exists within all cultures, giving a more rounded perspective, in my opinion, than THUG. As a blind individual, I related to the protagonist to some extent, particularly how she sometimes feels boxed in by her skin color. People expect certain things of her. People with disabilities have to struggle with this same problem: often, the world sees the disability and not the person as a whole. You sometimes feel like you have to work extra hard to prove yourself to others. It was wonderful that art was Jade’s outlet of self-expression. Music and theater was mine in school, and any form of art allows students to find unique ways to make themselves heard. I think kids will relate to Jade if they can just get past the fact that the pacing is slower than THUG. Both books have lots to say, and I am glad they both received recognition.

    • Janie says

      I appreciate your comments, Meredith. I think both books open up outsiders to the world these girls inhabit, and worthwhile for that reason.

Leave a Reply

Your email address will not be published. Required fields are marked *